I am older than my brother by approximately a year and a half. Which doesn’t mean a lot now. But back when we were kids?
I was THE boss.
He was a pretty decent sport about it, though. He’d let me make the executive decision to play beauty parlor or dress up regularly enough. And to show I wasn’t a heartless dictator, sometimes his teenage mutant ninja turtles would be allowed to save the day when it was time to have adventures with Barbie.
I know. I’m such a giver.
Anyway, little did he know, my power was self-appointed. And little did he know that I really had no idea what I was doing. Like ever.
Probably like most political leaders today. (ZING)
But that didn’t matter. So when I had the brilliant idea to recreate sledding in the middle of summer?
He was down to clown.
So how did we do it, you ask?
Well. Our house is on top of a hill. A hill just big enough to have a house on it and that’s it.
Anyway, there’s also a retaining wall built into the hill. It’s hard to explain, but basically imagine a steep hill and a wall at the bottom of it. With a tree was hanging out about 10 feet away from said wall.

I started making the cookies pretty like the traditional peanut butter cookie would be. But then I realized it wouldn’t matter in the end… time efficiency is important!
As a 5-year-old, I was pretty confident in my navigating abilities.
Yes. There was great confidence that I would be able to steer my little red wagon down a hill between two obstacles.
Did I mention I was 5 and also thought I could fly if I closed my eyes and wished it really really hard?

As for the “puppy chow” coating… you know I’m not one to make a dessert without chocolate being involved…
Long story short, the glory of flying down the hill in our little red wagon was a wonderful full 10 seconds before slamming directly into the retaining wall.
As the leader who wanted the best view, I was in front. Because I was in front, I also smacked into the retaining wall. Wagons didn’t have airbags back then.

Dipping the tops of cookies into the peanut butter chocolate coating. The original recipe requires you to dip the ENTIRE cookie into it… but that seemed almost excessive…
No brain damage occurred (shut it, I know what you’re thinking), but boy does the head bleed easily.
My brother was unharmed physically, which further strengthens the argument of why children should not sit in the front passenger seat until the age of 12, however, I think he was a little jarred emotionally as I was screaming and crying about ALL THE BLOOD OMG.
I do feel bad if there was any long term harm done. Sorry, brother.
Anyway… all the blood loss came from a teeny tiny cut in my head, and after a few days, my brother and I were back in cahoots together.
The whole reason I even bothered to tell you this long and drawn out story is that we were like two peas in a pod. No matter what the idea or scheme, I could always count on him as a backup. Whether it be flying down a hill like idiots, or most importantly, stealing as many cookies as possible from the kitchen.

The original recipe calls for way more powdered sugar. But I didn’t really find it necessary, either. The cookies are super rich as-is.
My mom used to make massive batches of puppy chow (muddy buddies- whatever) and leave it out to harden. As soon as she left the kitchen? Game on. In and out of the kitchen we’d go… mouths full of puppy chow.
It’s amazing my brother and I didn’t contract diabetes as children. Because when we weren’t stuffing our faces with freshly made cookies/sweets, we were spooning the dough out of the bowl. Or eating whipped cream out of the container.
Yes that happened and no, we’re not ashamed.
So there ya go. A double throwback to stories of a more innocent age and cookies that everyone in the world seemed to grow up with.
Those were the days…
For those of you who happen to love puppy chow as much as I do, here’s the recipe. Straight from the Betty Crocker website. Although I did actually make Martha Stewart’s peanut butter cookies on my own. Using the mix just wasn’t going to cut it this time. I couldn’t have eaten spoonfuls of peanut butter that way.
*Shoulder shrug*
And I swear I tried to find a picture of said hill/retaining wall. But alas… there isn’t one. So instead, here’s a picture of me bottle feeding a calf. 
Close enough.
Happy weekend!
Filed under: Random Baking Tagged: | baking, cookies, growing up, peanut butter, peanut butter cookies, puppy chow cookies






Puppy Chow was a mainstay in my childhood and is still the easiest most well-received thing to bring to a family function when I’m short on time. These cookies? Genius. Plus you don’t have to make a mess shaking a bunch of Chex in a bag with powdered sugar.
That’s a great story!
Between the story (awesome) and the cookies (awesome n a different way), I don’t know which I love more. Doesn’t matter though.
I want these cookies. Puppy chow is my best friend and my mortal enemy during the holidays.
Love sibling stories! And I don’t think I would’ve had any willpower with those cookies around. That frosting alone would do me in.
Yum-these cookies sound so good! And your brother sounds awesome!
ugh thanks for posting pics of those cookies…now i want some…
YOU STOP IT WITH THE COOKIES! Actually don’t, I love seeing them. Hot boots.
OMG, my sister and I used to get in so much trouble stealing the cookie dough when my mom made cookies. She literally would slap our hands away. So now I let Colin steal the dough (within reason) since my mom scarred me with that hand slapping.
OMG these cookies. Insane! I love puppy chow. I think I want to surprise my boyfriend with these. He’d love ‘em!
Haha, you were such a little dare devil! And I need those cookies. I can’t even imagine how good they are.
Best story ever! I can remember being little and begging my dad to let me take the wagon down the hill in the summer. And he always said no. I was so mad about it. Maybe it’s a good thing I didn’t have a sibling to encourage me : )
I didn’t even have puppy chow until I was a senior in high school. I had no idea such amazingness existed until then. Never had those cookies as a kid either. I think some things were definitely missing from my childhood now!
I love when your stories wind into baking tutorials- I feel like I’m sitting in the kitchen watching you make cookies while we chat
Those look like a delight!
I insist that you make these when we come to Chicago. And by make these I mean all for me
Ha! Love childhood stories. My brother is 2 years younger than me and we have multiple stories like this one. Oh to be young and think we are invincible again!
Puppy chow is the best ever, so obviously I need to make these.
P.S. I gave my brother a black eye with a frisbee once, totally on accident.
Oh I have never seen anything like this- these look incredible!
Bahaha!! I had an older brother and the fact we never broke anything major is an absolute miracle!
Those cookies look unreal. And I am a massive fan of puppy chow, don’t leave it in front of me.
These cookies are incredible!!
The chocolate dipped top takes them over the top!
I would love to bottle feed a calf! That is adorable!
Such a sweet story about your brother…I have a similar relationship with mine. I can (almost) always count on him!
Funny enough, we ate nothing but sugar when we were kids. Nothing. But. Sugar. As in, I ate ice cream for breakfast. Terrible and disgusting, now that I look back. And I am also amazed that neither of us developed diabetes!!
I can assure everyone they are as delicious as they look!